“A Voice for the Dead” by James E. Starrs with Katherine Ramsland

My quick spin on this book was it provided a nice reading experience of a true performance of a forensic scientist and investigator as he sought the truth from the grave as demonstrated in this book.

Book

Click here for image source.

PROFESSOR JAMES E. STARRS, A MODERN DAY SHERLOCK HOLMES

James Starrs has led a remarkable journey throughout his life. He has been an educator in the fields of law and forensic science. He has used his thought provoking abilities to uncover and bring forward significant information based on his exhumations.

Through the use of advanced technology, which obviously includes DNA testing, Professor Starrs takes his readers into his world by providing a true accounting of his exhumation projects. As costly as these projects are, his analysis based on his forensic analysis with the help of his colleagues have provided an avenue of exploring historically documented “facts,” in such a manner that in searching for the truth, the reader won’t be able to put the book down.

The intrigue of the core subject of this book is spelled out, in part, with the dedication page which succinctly states, “To the ones whose voices have not yet been heard but deserve to be.”

Starrs image

Click here for image source.

Click here for more biographical information on Dr. Starrs.

ALFRED PACKER – KILLER AND CANNIBAL?

One of Professor Starrs projects involved an incident that occurred over 100 years ago in Colorado relating to the fact that while Alfred Packer and five others endure a wintry expedition, only Packer survivevs. While cannibalism was said to have occurred by Packer’s recounting the experience of survival in the snowy mountains near Lake City, Colorado, it remains to be determined whether the act of cannibalism can be proven.

What Professor Starrs brings to the surface is curiosity and wonderment for the reader. He takes you through the whole journey from the beginning of crew or team gathering into what they find based on all their respective skills and expertise. This journalistic style continues throughout the book.

A Packer

Alfred Packer (Source: Wikipedia; public domain).

DR. FRANK OLSON – DID HE REALLY COMMIT SUICIDE IN 1953?

One of the most interesting cases in Professor Starrs’ book is about former CIA Agent, Frank Olson. I did recall watching a news documentary about this story prior to reading this book. Professor Starrs was clearly on a mission to determine whether Dr. Olson had committed suicide from a 13th floor of a hotel building, or if he was pushed out the window.

Dr. Olson’s oldest son never believed his father had committed suicide. Dr. Olson’s body was exhumed for the purpose of determining how his death occurred. I found this segment of the book involving the subject of a biological warfare programs surrounding the subject of LSD testing on individuals to be both intriguing and interesting. The nail biter is turning page after page with diligent reading to reach Professor Starrs’ conclusions.

As reported by the Associated Press in November 2012, two of Dr. Olson’s sons are suing the government for their father’s death. See this story here. The Olson sons have a site called the Frank Olson Project, a site in which you can read Chapter 3 of Professor Starrs’ book. This chapter and the family site are very compelling to study and research.

Click here for a profile of Dr. James Starrs.

 

Advertisements

Who Invented the Mugshot?

Meet the inventor of the mug shot: Frenchman, police officer and biometrics researcher who developed anthropometry which was beneficial to police officers in criminal identification.

One can only see what one observes, and one observes only things which are already in the mind. Alphonse Bertillon (4.24.1853 to 2.13.1914).

HISTORY OF ALPHONSE BERTILLON

Alphonse Bertillon was born in Paris, France. He had attempted a number of jobs before being called to serve with the French army at the age of 22. After serving in the army and not having a high level of education, his father and a medical professor Louis Bertillon, had influenced his hire into the Paris police. Bertillon’s brother, Jacques, also became successful including stepping into his father’s role after he died. Bertillon’s mother, Zoé, died very young at the age of 34 from the effects of a fever she was unable to break.

Some may have considered Bertillon to be a bit aloof since he wasn’t gifted with social skills. He was intelligent and he presented himself well. While working as a clerk for the Parisian police, it was Bertillon’s chief goal to help promote a system that could identify repeat offenders more expeditiously. Bertillon developed a method of identification which became known as Bertillonage and although repeat offenders could become identified, in time, this process was proven to be flawed when measurements were not taken accurately. For example, although consideration was given to a host of different measurements of any one particular individual in comparison to one element of measurement such as head size, imagine two people having the same measurement across their foreheads. Ultimately, this method would be replaced by a more effective measure known as fingerprinting. Noteworthy, Bertillon didn’t just rely on body measurements; he also used other physical characteristics such as scarring and personality factors.

Bertillon actually had developed a good idea to create a system that could identify someone who might be a repeat offender which, again, was a large part of his goal. It was found, though, that a person’s measurements could change just through the process of aging. Once fingerprinting came along, some of his fame was extinguished although he did incorporate the fingerprinting process into his method of identification. Fingerprinting, however, is quite unique per person.

In being a product of a prestigious family and the fact there were other physicians in his family, Bertillon was never considered to be another diamond. However, that being said, through the use of his experience with the police department, he became a criminologist and this would bring him fame in another type of laboratory.

Bertillon died at the age of 61 in Switzerland. Although his method soon faded after fingerprinting was adopted, he or his ego didn’t embrace the replacement identification method. Regardless, Bertillon is still viewed as the one who broke new ground into criminal identification.

7723333_f248

The photo above depicts a classroom where the subject of Bertillon’s method of criminal identification is being taught. (Source: http://Wikipedia.)

WHAT IS BIOMETRICS?

The study of the characteristics and traits of a human being for identification purposes is the simple explanation of biometrics. There are different types of biometrics dependent upon the need. Obviously, with computer science, this method is an identifier of sorts that reaches into a database of information. Through Bertillon’s research, he developed anthropometry which is further described below.

7723350_f496

The illustration above is from an article entitled, “The Speaking Portrait,” from “Pearson’s Magazine,” published in 1901, which depicts Bertillon’s principles of anthropometry. (Source: http://Wikipedia; this image is in the public domain because copyright has expired.)

WHAT IS ANTHROPOMETRY?

Anthropometry is essentially a technique used that would measure a person, hence the study of body measurements. In the 1880s, Bertillon opined that every individual would have different measurable physical characteristics.

The measurements also included other elements such as eyes and ears. This information was stored on cards which also contained a photo of the offender and processed into a filing system. Because Bertillon was able to identify over 200 offenders in 1884, other countries adopted his method. When this method was used in the United States, the centralized filing system of Bertillon cards was housed in Chicago.

7723368_f496

The image above was a self-portrait taken of Bertillon August 22, 1900. (Source: http://Wikipedia; this image is in the public domain because the copyright has expired.)

THE MUG SHOT

Bertillon also developed the standard of an offender’s mug shot and taking pictures of evidence prior to a crime scene being touched. Bertillon helped to shape other types of forensics practices, one of which could include examining whether a person’s signature on a document is forged or not essentially known as handwriting analysis today. He also contributed to the subject of preserving footprints.

Before Bertillon’s method of measurements was used, other than a system that wasn’t well organized, notes, photographs, or other less measures were used to try to identify or catch a criminal. Bertillon’s method was used for nearly three decades before fingerprinting came into use and at least his method was a form of advancement as well as an improved system. His development of the mug shot, however, is still deployed today.

7723596_f496

The above image is an example of a Bertillon card identifier. (Source: http://research.archives.gov/description/646350.)  This image describes John Welshouse, a sailor, who was arrested at the age of 29 for violating the White Slavery Act in New Orleans, better known as prostitution. He received one year and one day for his sentence to have expired on January 22, 1915. Interestingly and unrelated to the main subject, Welshouse’s wife made inquiry of him to the prison’s warden, who wrote back indicating his sentence was reduced and he was provided transportation to Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

The image is an example of one of Bertillon’s “cards” which has all the indicators represented of measurements taken to secure Welshouse’s identity and obviously, the mug shot image is of great benefit.